BOSE PS1 review
Click to Stay Tuned... 24-08-05
Review Bose® PS1 - PODxt Live - Variax... 25-08-05
Scott Carlson wrote a personal review in a (not so) rude mood. Writing down his impressions of the Bose® Personalized Amplification System™ system while using it with his band. He's using a PODxt Live and a Variax 700 aswell. He read other reviews that helped him and put together this one to do the same.
In the review he touches the setup, the creative proces of making his tones on the PODxt and ease of use. Feedback (the bad kind) isn't an issue, it's fasts set-up and more
source:Scott Carlson; used with permission
Bose® PS1 User review Scott Carlson... 25-08-05
I've been gigging with a PS1
(w/ one bass unit), Podxt Live and Variax 700 for most of 2005 and
wanted to share my experience with others and also hear what others
have discovered using them together in a live environment.
Volume & (no) Feedback
The only concerns I have had with volume is that some of the younger audience clubs have wanted the band to play at volumes which tire out my ears from the stage (we are a trio using three PS1s), yet the club has always been pleased with the overall volume from the band and not many have asked for such high volumes.
Feedback has not been a problem once we used the mics suggested by Bose and only creeps up when we play too loudly on small stages where the units are 2-3 feet behind us. Although everyone has different taste, it's difficult for me to believe that a decent guitar player can't get their tone to sound excellent through this setup to at least 95% of the audience.
The remaining 5% will be fellow guitar player tone freaks, and die hard SRV fans, who appreciate slight differences in tone that an average audience doesn't care about as they enjoy drinking/dancing on a night out. I have a little experience with the former crowd as my band was an SRV tribute band for the past few years before changing focus to classic rock covers in 2005.
While doing the SRV tribute I used high quality tube amps and analog effects from all the popular people on the internet (Analogman, Keeley, Reese, Klon). Although I admit that the rig sounded great when set up properly, I don't think it sounded better enough to miss all of the pre-gig setup hassles I abandoned by switching to the PS1, Podxt live and Variax.
Up and away in 20 minutes
My setup now takes 20 minutes and all the equipment fits in the trunk of a regular car. I power the PS1 through a furman power factor pro and regardless of the quality of electrical current available at a venue, I now have a guitar rig that consistently sounds live like I intended it to sound.
The Mode Mood
After much experimentation, I've settled on using my Podxt Live in the Bose output mode instead of Studio Direct. There is no strong reason I can give for this decision but you need to choose either one or the other if you intend to use all the patches at a live gig. I had an easier time developing patches that I liked in the Bose output mode (maybe because you don't need to tweak mic type, mic placement and % of room).
The downside to exclusively using the Bose output mode is that all song patches I have carefully tweaked while listening through the PS1 don't sound as good in other applications (ie, recording direct, direct out to house PAs, rehearsing with the band through headphones) as they would with the AIR modeling.
The Creative Patching Proces
I start out creating a new cover song patch by researching what equipment the guitarist used on the recording, then I play a recorded version of the song in my iPOD through the Aux Input of the Podxt Live and work toward matching the guitar tone as closely as possible with the pod and variax. I usually also further tweak it live because what sounds good by yourself does not always sound good when playing with drums/bass.
I find that most of my patches through the PS1 start behaving like a real guitar amp (ie, sustain notes & feedback if I want it) when I use the Pod's main compressor (not stompbox compressors) to boost gain (from 4-14) with 0db threshold. After playing around alot with the Pod's main EQ, I've settled on using it flat on almost all electric guitar patches and using the amps tone controls and/or the stompbox "fx boost + EQ" when I need tweaking beyond the amp.
Since I've been working on guitar
patches for almost all cover songs we perform, I try to match all levels
before hand but always set volume pedal min on 50% so that I can adjust
as necessary during songs and have plenty of room for solos. I use
the Podxt live's mono output into channel 4 of the Bose system with
the level set at about 2-3 and appreciate that I don't need to worry
about overdriving the channel input even with the volume pedal at 100%.
Playing live the Podxt has been very reliable but early on I had difficulty activating only the buttons I wanted. In contrast to my analog pedal switches, the Pod's switches were larger, closer together and only required light foot pressure. A few times while both singing and adjusting volume with the pedal, I inadvertantly activated the adjacient tuner switch and killed all sound from my guitar.
I fixed this by purchasing the Line 6 external pedal and using that exclusively for volume control on all patches. This has also had the benefit of always leaving the other pedal available for wah use without changing the overall volume when first activated. It used to drive me nuts activating the wah and getting a simultaneous boost to 100% volume.
I can't say that I'm completely happy with the tone from the podxt Live wah as compared to my Reese TMC3, but I hope line6 updates the software in the future and allows for greater control over Q frequency and bass/treble. In the meantime, I find solace in the belief that 95% of the audience won't notice the difference even if I could adjust the wah in the future. I also got used to lightly touching the patch buttons with the side of my shoe to avoid hitting surrounding ones.
The only other consistent problem has been using the Podxt Live at outdoor daytime gigs. The sun reacts with the orange LED window in such a way that you can't read what it says anymore. I solved this problem with a five inch high cardboard square (from shoebox) that fits around the Podxt live display and I tape it there for live daytime gigs to shade the display.
Let it Sync
Although the Podxt Live doesn't have a metronome for rehearsal, I've set all of my cover and original song patches with delay settings set to note values and then input the song's actual tempo in bpm at the "pedal/tweak/tempo" screen. When the patch is then selected, it shows me the preferred song tempo by the rate of the blinking red LED near the Tap button even when delay is not selected as an active effect.
Setting the tempos invdividually
for songs also has the side benefit of making the Stomp, Mod or Delay
effects which use tempo to sound consistently great. I can always adjust
tempo live with the tap switch if the band performs the song at a different
tempo and then the patch tempo reverts back to the original song tempo
if I don't save the new tap setting anyway.
Also, the variax pickup selector doesn't create the same sound on the Spank model as it does when you rapidly flick it on the SRV strat during a song like Voodoo Chile. In the meantime, I bring my real strat to gigs as my backup to use on all SRV tunes and then use the variax for everything else.
I've been frustrated with string breakage on the Variax and have not been able to solve it by using graph tech saddles like my other guitars. After the years of copying SRV's style, I tend to use an agressive pick attack and this shortens the life span of most strings.
Elixer for the Variax
Prior to performing with the variax, I used inexpensive bulk generic strings on all my guitars and changed them after every gig, but these broke within the first hour of playing the variax. I then started using more expensive Elixir and/or Firewire guage .011-.049 guitar strings and can now get through one 3-4 hour gig without breaking a string.
Also, a few months ago a guitar tech carefully filed the saddles smoother and that has helped as well. Maybe a future variax model will feature graph tech saddles. The acoustic models sound great on the variax and I use the patch that someone from Bose posted. It's very cool to play a Queen song like "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" and switch guitars mid-song from acoustic to Tele by stepping on one switch during the lead.
I love going from an open G tuning to regular tuning just by stepping on a Podxt live pedal and never take my Gibson ES335 to a gig anymore for slide work. Also, I like to tune down a half-step for my vocals and our female bass player prefers cover songs in their original key. With the variax, I can remain in half-step down tuning throughout the entire gig and play in regular tuning for her lead vocal songs just by stepping on one button.
The foregoing versatility has saved me from hauling 3-4 guitars to each gig. I don't miss the whammy bar on my variax as the maple neck is securely attached to the body and easily takes the abuse of using your right or left hand to bend it forward to lower string frequency. I didn't like the metal volume/tone control knobs on my variax 700 because you couldn't look down and see what state they were in.
I recently replaced
them with traditional knobs with numbers and would recommend this to
anyone who likes to adjust vol/tone during songs. I haven't really
experimented much with Workbench but would like to know if anyone has
created a guitar patch that sounds like Brian Mays red special. I also
haven't used Line 6's "Edit" program much except to save my patches
in order of setlist and move them around before a gig if something
The Band Gear
*Line 6®, Line 6 Inc., AX2, AxSys, BackTrack, BackTrack+Mic, Bass Floor POD®, Bass POD®, Bass POD® xt, Bass POD® xt Pro, Bass POD® xt Live, Constrictor™, Crunchtone™, Customtone, Duoverb, DL4™, DM4™, Echo Park™, Eight Ball, Filter Pro™, Flextone™, Floorboard, Floor POD®, Floor POD® Plus, FBV Express™, GearBox™, GearBox™ Plug-In, Guitarport™, GuitarPort® RiffTracker™, GuitarPort® xt, FM4™, HD147®, Jamware, JM4 Looper, LowDown, Liqua Flange™, M13, MM4™, MOD Pro, POD®, Pocket POD®, Pocket POD® Express, POD® FARM, POD® Studio, POD® xt, POD®xt Pro, POD® xt Live, POD® X3, POD® X3 Pro, POD® X3 Live, Rifftracker™, Roto Machine™, Space Chorus™, Spider™, Spider-Jam™, Spider-Valve™, ToneCore™, TonePort™, TubeTone, Ubermetal™, GX, UX1, UX2, UX8, Verbzilla™, Vetta™, Variax®, Variax® Acoustic, Variax® Workbench™ and Line 6 logos are trademarks of Line 6,
Inc. RiffWorks, InstantDrummer™, Riffcaster, Rifflink and Sonoma Wire Works™ are trademarks of Sonoma Wire Works™.
Atomic, Atomic Amps, LLC, Atomic Reactor 112, Atomic Reactor 112-50 and Atomic Reactor 212 are trademarks of Atomic Amps.
Bose® and Bose® Personalized Amplification System™ are registered trademarks of Bose. T1 Tonematch, L1, All rights reserved.
Vinny appears exclusively
for Vettaville.nl with courtesy of Vettaville Records Inc.
All other product names used on this website are trademarks of their respective owners, which are in no way associated or affiliated with Vettaville.nl or Vettaville.net. These trademarks of other manufacturers are used solely to identify the products of those manufacturers to identify a certain tone or sound.
Entire contents Copyright
© 2003-2008 Vettaville.nl. All Rights Reserved.
Copyright © Vettaville.nl 2003-2008, All rights reserved.